Ed Melcarek
From a “Jack to a King”, a True Story. After years of being a company man and team player, I found myself trying to rescue my floundering career after being given my walking papers. My resume didn’t open the doors it used to, and nobody wanted my skills as a design engineer in the local marketplace. The usual reason given by prospective employers for not hiring me was ” too diverse a set of skills and experience” or, “not a good fit” for our needs. If I was to hire someone to be a design engineer, I would regard any extra pertinent knowledge the applicant has, a positive attribute. After many years, I found that there aren’t many people like me doing the hiring out there in the real world. Apparently, I found that during the course of an interview, a trivial matter such as the color of one’s shirt or tie can influence whether or not you get the job. An interviewer always had a hidden agenda and criteria by which the final decision was made. My qualifications, most often, had little to do with that decision. After giving up jumping through many inteviewers’ hoops, I decided to strike out on my own to survive in the jungle.
Burning my engineering reference library, throwing away my address book, changing my name, getting a face lift, etc. all crossed my mind. Then one day, by chance, I ran across an interesting website on the internet called InnoCentive. Here was a list of engineering problems posted for solutions by this company for cash awards. After much review and scrutiny, I concluded that it was legitimate and worthy of my time, and just as important, had nothing to do with politics, just science. Heck, I had little to lose with my finances down to my last dollar. Also, it confirmed my long standing notion of the trend in the corporate R&D world. It dawned on me that these posted problems can be solved ONLY IF, you have “too diverse a set of skills and experience”, something that the corporate world frowns upon, after all, thinking “out of the box” is not something one is paid for in the corporate world.
I posted and subsequently won my first award, back in ’03.That award saved me from the welfare office, and re-affirmed my confidence in myself. My batteries were re-charged again..From that point in time onwards, I’ve won six more awards and am always writing solutions for InnoCentive Challenges. I’ve invested heavily in design & modeling software, and have become somewhat financially independent. Also, I’ve given up trying to fit round pegs into a square holes and jumping through corporate status quo hoops. InnoCentive does all that work with their seeker companies, and lets me just do the science; A dream job, considering that I get to choose the Challenges I want to work on. I’ve incorporated in the U.S., set up a website, and am also active now in submitting solutions to the U.S. Department of Defence projects through the SBIR / STTR programs. In addition, I plan to invest in InnoCentive stocks with my next awards. After all, it’s the only company I know of that pays it’s solvers to think “out of the box”. I’ve come to believe, “Look at what everybody else is doing, and don’t do it !” A good formula for success these days, and it’s working for me.
Written by Ed Melcarek, C.E.T. / Ph.D, Sono-Dyne Inc.
Tags: Ed Melcarek, engineer, retiree


August 22nd, 2008 at 9:26 am
[...] Blog Team InnoCentive.com « Ed Melcarek [...]
August 25th, 2008 at 1:00 pm
Your story is an inspiration for all true Engineers. Having myself a long track record in maintenance in the shop floor, I know the value of the “think outside the box” attitude. I believe we will get to the point when people will start rediscovering how invaluable this asset is, and the creation and success of InnoCentive may be an indication.
Congratulations.
September 11th, 2008 at 10:25 am
Hi,
Your story is verymuch motivational to so many who really has versatile skill sets and enthusiasm to do innovative things when they can not do while doing a regular as usual monthly or weekly pay job per hour.Inshort anyone who has real talent and not getting oppurtunities then they can really consider you as rolemodel..
November 6th, 2008 at 7:23 pm
Great story, Ed! It is very much like mine in your experiences and in the fact that we bring varied talents and creativity to the table that Corporate cultures seldom appreciate! Rock on and thanks for the inspiration!
March 17th, 2009 at 2:04 pm
[...] Ed Melcarek, a freelance engineer who was making his money installing HVAC systems in Barre, Ontario. He [...]
March 19th, 2009 at 7:12 am
[...] Ed Melcarek, a freelance engineer who was making his money installing HVAC systems in Barre, Ontario. He [...]
July 10th, 2009 at 3:13 pm
[...] Let me leave you with an excerpt from a blog post from one of our 2007 Top Solvers, Ed Melcarek: [...]
February 5th, 2010 at 1:27 am
[...] Ed Melcarek, el canadiense que envió su idea para la solución, gano US$25,000 por sus esfuerzos, que solo es una fracción de lo que hubiese costado a Colgate-Palmolive solucionar el problema internamente. Melcarek es parte de una comunidad de más de 180,000 científicos que resuelven problemas de Investigación & Desarrollo de compañías de la lista Fortune 100, en su tiempo libre. Esta comunidad esta albergada en InnoCentive, una compañía creada en 2001, cuyo objetivo es facilitar un marketplace para que las empresas encuentren talento para solucionar problemas de muy alto nivel. [...]
June 22nd, 2010 at 9:58 am
[...] and ideas we’ve received from you. Today’s post is a summary of a submission by Ed Melcarek, who is a seven-time winning InnoCentive [...]
June 30th, 2010 at 10:09 pm
Ed,
BP Funnel … Nice idea I was thinking of something more crude (pardon the pun) but just a massive reservoir built around the gusher (if all else fails).. naturally would be massive say 50 to … XXXX ft wide and 2 miles high to the surface. The Oil could fill it with out being spread around while being reclaimed. As yours containing the problem as opposed to sealing a leak. I think yours is more elegant. I guess in this case 2 eds are not better than 1.
Cheers
Ed